11 best shallow subs
A "shallow sub" refers to a type of subwoofer that is designed to fit into tight spaces, particularly in vehicles like cars or trucks where space is limited. Shallow subs are commonly used in car audio systems to provide enhanced bass and low-frequency sound without taking up too much room in the vehicle's trunk or cabin.Here are some key points about shallow subs:
Compact Design: Shallow subs are engineered with a slim and compact design. They have a low profile and a reduced mounting depth compared to traditional subwoofers, allowing them to fit in smaller enclosures or under seats.
Space-Saving: One of the primary advantages of shallow subs is their ability to save space. This is especially valuable in vehicles where trunk or cabin space is at a premium. Shallow subs make it possible to enjoy deep bass without sacrificing cargo space or passenger comfort.
Performance: While shallow subs are designed to be space-efficient, they are still capable of delivering impressive bass performance. They can reproduce low-frequency sounds effectively, enhancing the overall audio experience in a car audio system.
Enclosure Type: Shallow subs are often used in sealed enclosures (also known as "sealed boxes") to maximize their performance. Sealed enclosures provide tight and accurate bass response, which is well-suited for various music genres.
Power Handling: Shallow subs come in various power handling ratings, which determine how much power they can handle from an external amplifier. It's essential to match the subwoofer's power handling capability with the amplifier's output to prevent damage and achieve optimal sound quality.
Wiring and Installation: Like traditional subwoofers, shallow subs require proper wiring and installation. This includes connecting them to an amplifier, ensuring the electrical connections are secure, and properly setting up the audio system for balanced sound.
Compatibility: When considering a shallow sub for a car audio system, it's crucial to check its compatibility with your vehicle and available space. Some shallow subs are designed specifically for certain vehicle models or require custom enclosures.
Sound Quality: Shallow subs can deliver excellent sound quality, but the overall listening experience also depends on factors like the quality of the subwoofer itself, the enclosure, and the tuning of the audio system.
In summary, shallow subs are a space-saving solution for adding powerful bass and low-frequency sound to car audio systems. Their compact design makes them suitable for vehicles with limited space, and they can deliver impressive bass performance when properly installed and matched with the rest of the audio system components.
Below you can find our editor's choice of the best shallow subs on the marketProduct description
The Skar Audio VD-12 D2 is a 12-inch, dual 2-ohm, shallow mount car subwoofer. This woofer was engineered to sound great and handle ample amounts of power all while maintaining a shallow foot print, which allows them to be very versatile in use. This driver utilizes a high temperature 2-inch voice coil, which in conjunction with it's powerful, yet low profile single stack ferrite magnet, allow it to perform with dominance. The VD series make for a great under seat subwoofer or for use in applications where mounting depth is limited. 12-inch car subwoofer. Dual 2 ohm voice coil. Max power: 800 Watts. RMS Power: 500 Watts. Fs: 35.3 Hz, Spl: 86.7 dB. Mounting Depth: 4.92"
- 12-Inch Dual 2 ohm Shallow Mount Subwoofer
- Peak Power: 800 Watts | RMS Power: 500 Watts
- Shallow Mount Design - Mounting Depth: 4.92"
- High Performance Pressed Paper Cone Stitched to Premium Foam Surround
- Sensitivity: 86.7 dB | Fs: 35.3 Hz
- Frequency Response: 25 Hz - 300 Hz
User questions & answers
Question: | Can I run 2 12 vd -12 d4 can they handle a 1ohm loaf if I wore it that way |
Answer: | Well, if you want to drop them to a 2ohm load, you'll need to of them with dual 4ohm voice coils. You should probably counsolt your local car audio professional before attempting. But all the VD subwoofers can handle a 1ohm load |
Question: | I have a 1100wat boss audio amp will it power 2 of these 2 Ohm 12s |
Answer: | Man I never ever heard of tht amp |
Question: | What do y’all recommend to put behind a 1999 ram single cab |
Answer: | I would go with 8" skar, they do hit hard, if you want to hit lows in rap music go with 12s |
Question: | What if my amp is only 500 watts max power. will it still power the subwoofer |
Answer: | Do not listen to anyone who says you can damage a speaker by "under-powering" it. If you are listening to music at very low volumes you are not damaging your equipment and are only sending a couple of Watts or less to the drivers. Driver damage comes from trying to pull more power from your amp than it can safely deliver driving it to clipping the output signal (assuming the input signal is not already clipped). So yes your 500 Watt max power (Likely 250 Watts RMS) will still power the speaker just fine, it just might not get as loud as you'd like. |
Product features
Technical Specifications
- Dual 2 Ohm Voice Coil Configuration
- Peak Power: 800 Watts
- RMS Power: 500 Watts
- Pressed Paper Cone
- High Roll Foam Surround
- 2" High Temperature Copper Voice Coil
- Frequency Response: 25 - 300 Hz
- Sensitivity: 86.7 dB
- Xmax: 11 mm
- Mounting Depth: 4.92"
Product description
Since day one, we have spearheaded the car audio revolution. Nothing has changed. Rockford Fosgate is still the global leader in audio innovation and your passion is our purpose. We engineer the best audio systems for your lifestyle!
- High-flow, low-noise port design.
- Constructed with 5/8-Inch MDF
- 11 AWG input terminals
- Dimensions: (inches)13.5" x 27.375" x 5.25" (bottom) x 3.25" (top)
User questions & answers
Question: | Will it fit behind the seat of a 2014 f |
Answer: | I would think it would. We had it behind the seat of an 87 gmc truck. |
Question: | Does anyone know if this will fit behind a reg cab 2nd gen tacoma |
Answer: | No. I have a 2nd gen Tacoma and a full size GMC. It will fit in the GMC but not in the Tacoma. |
Question: | What's the ohm rating |
Answer: | Its a 4 ohm dvc wired inside to give you a 2 ohm load. Hope this helps, if not I will be glad to answer more questions if needed. |
Question: | What wiring kit should I buy for this |
Answer: | We went with a 4 Gauge wire kit like this: http://www.amazon.com/Rockford-Fosgate-RFK4X-Complete-Amplifier/dp/B0012BYOSK/ref=sr_1_5?ie=UTF8&qid=1390091839&sr=8-5&keywords=Complete+4+Gauge+Amplifier+Installation+Kit . We also added a 1.0 Farad Capacitor which is probably considered old school by today's installation practices, but it works and the punch from the Sub does not cause dimming of the lights and doesn't get hot. It was a great match up and now for over 6 months has performed very well. We also used a 600 Watt Sony Mono Amplifier as it match the spec's for the sub. Mind you, we don't push the sub hard like others may do... This sub and enclosure combo isn't made to do that, but it does give a pretty decent punch when demanded by the music being played. If you want a lot of punch then consider a different sub enclosure |
Product features
Rockford Fosgate R2S-1X12 R2 Shallow Prime Single 12-Inch Subwoofer Enclosure
Description:
When you have no space for bass, our PRIME R2S 12" shallow loaded enclosure is sure to be a perfect fit for your ride and your budget. These shallow loaded enclosures can fit in tight spaces due to the slim-line depth of 3.25" on the top and 5.25" on the bottom. The wedge design is optimized for single-cab trucks with limited seat travel.
- Constructed with 5/8" MDF
- Covered with high density carpet
- High current binding posts
Product description
By installing the subwoofer downward, the AS down-firing enclosures optimize bass response with superior efficiency for richer, deeper, heart pounding low frequency sounds regardless of the enclosure installed position. The sleek design of the AS enclosures allows for installation anywhere in the vehicle, they can be installed vertically or horizontally. The durable MDF wood construction is designed to reduce vibration. Additionally, a special bonding sealer is used to create an air-tight seal to increase joint strength as well as bass reflex. The spun aluminum cone stays rigid even with the most powerful bass notes. Alphasonik's compact down-firing enclosures perform superbly, producing extreme bass with minimal space. The current product description is inaccurate.
- power rating: 200 watts rms / 600 watts max
- cone material: spun aluminum cone, surround material: high strength rubber epdm enhanced surround
- final impedance: 4-ohm, copper wound kapton voice coil, push type terminals
- sensitivity: 90db, frequency response: 32hz - 500hz
- "enclosure dimensions: 12.09" x 5.7" x 9.45" / 307mm x 145mm x 240mm"
- Included components: Enclosure, Subwoofer, Mounting Hardware
User questions & answers
Question: | Cables included with this |
Answer: | No. Cables are not included. |
Question: | What type of wires do you need to go with this |
Answer: | I used 10 gauge duplex wiring. Bought it by 100" roll on amazon. |
Question: | Will this sub handle a 600 rms Rockford fosgate amplifie |
Answer: | No it will not handle 600 RMS. This sub is rated 200 RMS and 600 peak watts. When shopping for audio equipment It's best to try and match RMS of speakers and subs to RMS of the amplifier so you don't blow the speakers and subs. |
Question: | Will this fit behind a seat of a F |
Answer: | I had it in the floor in a Nissan Frontier Crew Cab, with no problem. Was actually pretty convenient, but it started to fail after 3 hours, so I got sent back. I’d say take the concept, build your own, and use a high quality subwoofer. |
Product description
####Item is open box, unharmed and in very good condition. All accessories or parts are included with the item.####
- Thin profile eclosure with loaded 10 inch subwoofer with single 2 ohm terminal
- Fits perfectly under or behind a vehicle's seat
- Features genuine CompC subwoofer with 600 watts max power, 300 watts of RMS power
- Custom ported design
- Box dimensions: 7.625 x 21.5 x 15 inches
User questions & answers
Question: | Is it amplified |
Answer: | No it is not |
Question: | What is the difference between 2 ohm and 4 ohm |
Answer: | The smaller the impedance of the speaker, the greater the power produced by an equivalent signal from the amplifier. A 4-ohm speaker will absorb twice as much power as an 8-ohm speaker, as long as they have the same signal level as the amplifier. 2 ohm against 4 ohm If the amplifier is set to drive a 2 ohm speaker, it will produce more acoustic power. If the amplifier is designed for 4 ohm speakers only, there is a risk that the amplifier will be damaged if a 2 ohm speaker is used. The main application of the 2 ohm speakers is in the woofers and subwoofers (those bass speakers). |
Question: | Is the subwoofer already wired to the box or do I need to remove the subwoofer and physically do it myself |
Answer: | Already wired to box. |
Question: | is this a dual voice cone speaker |
Answer: | this is a single voice coil. |
Product description
Since day one, we have spearheaded the car audio revolution. Nothing has changed. Rockford Fosgate is still the global leader in audio innovation and your passion is our purpose. We engineer the best audio systems for your lifestyle! Power Handling (Watts RMS): 200 Watts RMS,400 Watts Max
- Stamp-cast basket with integrated spider venting
- Mica injected polypropylene cone
- Mounting Depth 3.4 Inches ; 12 AWG compression terminals
- 400w Power Handling ; Anodized aluminum voice coil former
- Linear spider with stitched 16 AWG tinsel leads
User questions & answers
Question: | When it says 6x12x10 where actually are those measurements |
Answer: | The box the subwoofer comes in"useless info" |
Question: | What are the db on this sub |
Answer: | wizard. Rpckford Fosgate support for complete specs. This is not an SPL sub. Its more for sound quality builds. It does thump, but is not a vibrate the neighbors type of sub. |
Question: | What is the rms wattage |
Answer: | 200watts RMS with a Peek wattage of 400Watts |
Question: | Is it a single or dual voice coil |
Answer: | Dual voice coil. Don't push it pass 200 watts. It doesn't like it. |
Product features
Rockford Fosgate R2 Ultra Shallow 10-Inch 4 Ohm DVC Subwoofer
When you have no space for bass, our Prime R2SD4-10 shallow subwoofer will satisfy your need. This 10” subwoofer handles 200 Watts RMS and the 4-Ohm Dual Voice Coil design lets you to wire them in various configurations.When you have no space for bass, our R2 10" shallow subwoofer can help satisfy your need for low frequency music. These drivers can fit in tight spaces due to an elevated motor structure that reduces speaker depth. Mica injected polypropylene cones make sure bass notes are clean and accurate. Stamp-cast baskets feature spider venting typically reserved for traditional depth mounted models to keep the motor cool! These shallow subwoofers are optimized for sealed enclosures.
- 12 AWG compression terminals
- Anodized aluminum voice coil former
- Optimized for sealed enclosures
- Mica injected polypropylene cone
- Linear spider with embedded 16 AWG tinsel leads
- StampCast basket with integrated spider venting
- Integrated PVC trim ring
- Shallow Motor Assembly
Product description
Brand new Kenwood Excelon KFC-XW1200F 12 1400 watt shallow mount car subwoofer
- 12" 4-Ohm shallow-mount subwoofer
- Carbon-glass fiber composite Cone with butyl rubber surround
- Cast aluminum basket
- Power range: 50-350 watts RMS
User questions & answers
Question: | How do you mount it to the box? I dont see any mounting holes |
Answer: | Holes are under the rubber cover strip around the subwoofer |
Question: | If I mount this sub in a box with 1.7 Cubic FT would that be to much space in a sealed box for the sub to perform properly |
Answer: | i think that works perfectly from 1 to 2 FT i used in a original kenwood box |
Question: | is this for a set or just one |
Answer: | Just one, but if you want a clean sounding woofer it is a good one. |
Question: | Whic his better this sub or the pioneer ts-sw3002s4 12" sub |
Answer: | Well I don't k ow how the pioneer sounds but I did my homework and the kenwood got the best reviews and ratings until you get to like the JL audio that were almost 3 times the price and get only needed like .25 cf of airspace and as far as performance I was blown away at how much sound and how solid they were for a shallow mount sub. |
Product description
MB Quart discus 600 watt 10 inch shallow mount subwoofer with dual 4 ohm 2 inch voice coils, thermal formed poly cone, vented aluminum former and butyl surround. Less than 3 inches Mounting depth.
- Shallow Mount – With less than 3 inches mounting depth, this car subwoofer is ideal in sealed enclosure applications and makes for one of the most versatile subwoofers for cars in areas with limited space.
- Deep Bass - Front and rear venting allows cooler air to be exchanged in the voice coil gap which helps the sub make deep bass and extend the life of the component.
- Built to Last - Heavy gauge powder coated stamped steel basket provides a solid base for the motor system and moving parts and delivers big bass in a small space that does not consume your cargo space.
- High Performance - 2.5 inch high temperature voice coil and former for high thermal stability in small enclosure volumes where the internal box temperatures can rob you of performance.
- Heavy Duty – UV rubber surround resists sun fading and remains flexible and the nickel plated push and insert resists corrosion and make for ease of installation.
User questions & answers
Question: | Will this work for a home audio surround sound subwoofer |
Answer: | Yes when install in the proper enclosure, and proper amp. |
Question: | Does anybody know the frequency range of this speaker |
Answer: | The manufacturer does not disclose frequency response. But I can guarantee these 10” speakers are not full range and you would not want to play a 20k hz signal through these. |
Question: | Does this product cob with the screw |
Answer: | No screws no grill |
Question: | If i get 3 of the mb quart ds1-254 discus series, 400w, 10" shallow subwoofer, what type/size amp should i get with it |
Answer: | 3? How are you going to wire them ohm wise? That will dictate the amp. |
Product description
By installing the subwoofer downward, the AS down-firing enclosures optimize bass response with superior efficiency for richer, deeper, heart pounding low frequency sounds regardless of the enclosure installed position. The sleek design of the AS enclosures allows for installation anywhere in the vehicle, they can be installed vertically or horizontally. The durable MDF wood construction is designed to reduce vibration. Additionally, a special bonding sealer is used to create an air-tight seal to increase joint strength as well as bass reflex. The spun aluminum cone stays rigid even with the most powerful bass notes. Alphasonik's compact down-firing enclosures perform superbly, producing extreme bass with minimal space.
- Power Rating: 500 Watts RMS / 1500 Watts Max
- Cone Material: Spun Aluminum Cone | Surround Material: High Strength Rubber EPDM Enhanced Surround
- Final Impedance: 4-Ohm | Copper Wound Kapton Voice Coil | Push Type Terminals
- Sensitivity: 92dB | Frequency Response: 26Hz - 500Hz
- Enclosure Dimensions: 20.47" x 6.7" x 14.1" / 520mm x 170mm x 358mm
User questions & answers
Question: | Can I run one on a 1500 watt amp |
Answer: | Be careful not to blow it cuz sub is only about 4-500 rms.. I had 1 on a 1200.1D hifonics and went ahead and bought a 2nd to run so amp can get to full potential out of amp. |
Question: | Will the boss audio pt1600 phantom 1600 watt, 2 channel, 2/4 ohm stable class a/b, full range, bridgeable work with these subs |
Answer: | I can’t think of a reason it wouldn’t work. I run a boss 1500 and it sounds great so as long as your EQ and tune are good you’ll be fine. |
Question: | Can 4 of these be hooked up to a 1500 class d 1 ohm stable amp if so how would they hold up |
Answer: | They would hold up fine. Since these subs are dual 4ohm you could run three of them at 8ohms and the fourth at 2 ohms, and if you ran them all parallel after that it would bring your final impedance down to 1.14ohms. |
Question: | what pioneer amp would you recommend for 2 of these subs |
Answer: | run the single speakers in series, then run them both in parallel. 2@2 ohms in par. equals total off 4 ohms... i would recomend anyone with 800 plus watts rms |
Product description
Quality subwoofers are the backbone of any serious car audio setup, which is why serious audiophiles turn to the Kicker CompRT 12 Inch 1000 Watt 2 Ohm Shallow Subwoofer when they want awesome bass in less space. This sub is designed for shallow mounts with its mounting depth of 3.75 inches and a mounting diameter of 11 inches. Intended for sealed boxes with between 0.55 and 2.0 cubic feet of volume, or in vented boxes with 1.75 to 2.25 cubic feet of volume, this sub's 500 watts of RMS power and 2 ohms of impedance are sure to give your vehicle the powerful, rich sound you're after. This sub also features an injection molded polypropylene cone, high temperature voice coil, and weather resistant rubber surround so not even a little rain can stop the music the next time you're on the highway or off roading.
- CompRT 12 inch, shallow mount subwoofer
- Features 1,000 watts of max power and 500 watts of RMS power handling
- Rubber surround and weatherproof for outdoor use
- Injection molded polypropylene cone
- High temperature voice coils for increased power handling
User questions & answers
Question: | Are these shallow mount speakers |
Answer: | Yes they are shallow mount speakers |
Question: | Best amp to power these |
Answer: | Kicker CX800.1 one one, or Kicker CXA1200.1 on two. |
Question: | How can wire it to have a 2 ohm load on the amp |
Answer: | I've had mine in running 1500 watts through it for months and it still performs like new. I bought the box and everything but its the same 500rms 1000 peak 2 ohm that this one is |
Question: | How many watts rms/ peak and is it dual voice coils |
Answer: | Thank you for your question. This subwoofer is DVC, and it is 500 watts RMS. Happy to help! - Creative Audio |
Question: | I have a rockford fosgate prime r500-1 will it power 1 of these? it does 500watts at 2 ohms |
Answer: | Yes the RF R500.1 will power these with a little room to spare. The Massive UFO10 will have a final 2 ohm load. |
Question: | whats the mounting depth |
Answer: | The mounting depth is: 5.67 Inches |
Question: | Will a rockford fosgate 200ix run 2 of them |
Answer: | We would not suggest this amplifier for 2 of the UFO10 subwoofers due to lack of power and 1 ohm stability. |
Question: | Will a Jl 1000x1 push |
Answer: | 2 UFO woofers will be 600 watts RMS at 1 Ohm. Make sure your JL1000 can produce at least 600 watts @ 1 ohm RMS |
Product features
UFO Series Subwoofer
Massive Audio has always been known for cutting edge technology and some believe that knowledge must come from ET's. So, it’s not surprising their “UFO” slim mount subwoofers are out of this world. These super slim heavy hitters feature Dual 4-ohm 2.5" voice coils and are designed to “Produce Big Bass in Any Space” They do it all while orbiting earth at 300 Watts RMS / 600 Watts MAX power and with under a “3.1” mounting depth!
Product description
This MB Quart Discus Series 8 in. 400-Watt Shallow Subwoofer is based on the company's popular RLP shallow subs. The steel baskets are stamp-cast and deep drawn. And it will work well in either sealed or ported applications.
- Shallow Mount – With less than 3 inches mounting depth, this car subwoofer is ideal in sealed enclosure applications and makes for one of the most versatile subwoofers for cars in areas with limited space.
- Deep Bass - Front and rear venting allows cooler air to be exchanged in the voice coil gap which helps the sub make deep bass and extend the life of the component.
- Built to Last - Heavy gauge powder coated stamped steel basket provides a solid base for the motor system and moving parts and delivers big bass in a small space that does not consume your cargo space.
- High Performance - 2 inch high temperature voice coil and former for high thermal stability in small enclosure volumes where the internal box temperatures can rob you of performance.
- Heavy Duty – UV rubber surround resists sun fading and remains flexible and the nickel plated push and insert resists corrosion and make for ease of installation.
User questions & answers
Question: | Will this fit a 05 f |
Answer: | Great question! This subwoofer will fit but an enclosure would need to be made as these are to be installed where there is limited space and are not a vehicle specific subwoofer. Check out the manual for specific box size recommendations. I hope this helps, and please let us know if you have any other questions. MB Quart (Powered by Maxxsonics) |
Question: | Can this speaker replace the factory sub in my 2001 gmc yukon |
Answer: | I replaced my factory sub with this mb quartz on my 2002 gmc yukon xl. Its a longer vehicle than yours but i think the configuration/sub enclosure is the same or very similar. The great thing about this mb quartz is it's thin profile (not deep at all) allowing it to insert and fit perfectly into the factory sub enclosure. I did have to drill a few new holes around the sub enclosure for the mountings screws that mount the mb quartz. Speaker itself sounds great. Good bass. |
Question: | what is the least volume space needed |
Answer: | 0.5ft^3 is recommended. mbquart.com/media/mconnect_uploadfiles/d/s/ds1-254_quick_start_guide_rev2.pdfIts on the top right of the PDF. |
Question: | Hom many ohm ? How many Voice coil ? No much information about this sub on the description |
Answer: | Power Handling: Peak: 400 watts RMS: 200 wattsPolypropylene cone and dust capUV Rubber surround2" Dual Voice CoilAll new design based on popular RLP shallow subsStamp-cast deep drawn steel basketDurable heavy textured powder coatVented aluminum voice coil formerOptimized for sealed enclosuresNickel plated spring terminalsHardware concealing rubber gasket trimTop-mount depth: 2.80"Cutout diameter: 7.24"Sensitivity: 81 dB |
Product description
This is a package deal for 2 Brand New Skar Audio VD-12 Dual 4-ohm subwoofers. The Skar Audio VD-12 D4 is a 12-inch, Dual 4-ohm, shallow mount car subwoofer. This subwoofer was engineered to sound great and handle ample amounts of power all while maintaining a shallow footprint, which allows them to be very versatile as well as get loud. This driver utilizes a high temperature 2-inch voice coil, which in conjunction with it's powerful, yet low profile single stack ferrite magnet, allow it to perform with dominance. The vd Series make for a great under seat subwoofer or for use in applications where mounting depth is limited. Shallow mount 12-inch car subwoofer. Dual 4-ohm voice coil. Max power: 800 Watts. Rms power: 500 Watts. Fs: 36.6 Hz, SPL: 85.9 dB, useable Frequency range: 35 Hz - 300 Hz, mounting depth: 4.92"
- Sold as a package - includes Skar Audio vd-12 D4 12-inch Dual 4 ohm shallow mount subwoofers
- Peak Power: 800 watts (each) | RMS Power: 500 watts (each)
- Shallow mount subwoofer design - mounting depth: 4. 92" | Sensitivity: 85.9 dB
- Frequency response: 35 Hz - 300 Hz | 2" High temperature voice coil
- Pressed paper cone and stitched foam Surround
User questions & answers
Question: | Cut out diameter |
Answer: | 11.3” |
Question: | What size amp do you recommend running thesr 2 subs |
Answer: | 1000 rms to 1500 rms amp will work just fine for these. |
Question: | I have a extended cab chevy Silverado with a q boom down fire box with a Rockford fosgate prime 1200 do you think they will do good in that type box |
Answer: | I don’t know what your air space is in that particular box. Mine was .95 I added 1/2 # of poly fill to each chamber and I’m running an MTX 1200 mono, and she hits hard. You’ll definitely need to do an alternator upgrade and the big 3 wire upgrade if you haven’t already done that. |
Question: | What kind of screws would I need to screw them into my box |
Answer: | I used 1in wood screws. |
Latest Reviews
View all
Golf Instructions
- Updated: 24.06.2023
- Read reviews

Onstage Guitar Cases
- Updated: 10.05.2023
- Read reviews

Swimming Paddles
- Updated: 30.03.2023
- Read reviews

Boss Front Camera For Cars
- Updated: 17.04.2023
- Read reviews

Amir Humidifiers
- Updated: 21.06.2023
- Read reviews