8 best rolled sugar cookie icing recipe

A rolled sugar cookie icing recipe is used to create a smooth and colorful icing that can be spread or drizzled over rolled sugar cookies. It's an essential component of decorating sugar cookies for various occasions, such as holidays, birthdays, and special events. Here's a basic rolled sugar cookie icing recipe:

Ingredients:

  • 2 cups confectioners' sugar (powdered sugar)
  • 2 tablespoons milk (whole milk works best)
  • 2 tablespoons light corn syrup
  • 1/2 teaspoon pure vanilla extract (optional)
  • Food coloring (gel or liquid) in your choice of colors

Instructions:

  1. Prepare the Ingredients: Measure out the confectioners' sugar, milk, light corn syrup, and vanilla extract (if using) before you begin.

  2. Mix the Icing: In a medium-sized mixing bowl, combine the confectioners' sugar and milk. Stir until the mixture is smooth and all the sugar is dissolved.

  3. Add Corn Syrup: Add the light corn syrup to the mixture and stir well. The corn syrup adds shine and helps the icing set.

  4. Add Flavor (Optional): If you'd like to add flavor to your icing, such as vanilla, you can do so at this stage. Stir in the vanilla extract until well incorporated.

  5. Color the Icing: Divide the icing into separate bowls if you want to create different colored icings. Add a few drops of food coloring to each bowl and mix until you achieve the desired colors. Gel food coloring tends to be more vibrant than liquid food coloring.

  6. Decorate the Cookies: Once your icing is ready, you can spread it onto your cooled, baked sugar cookies using a spatula or knife. Alternatively, you can use piping bags and tips to create intricate designs and decorations.

  7. Let the Icing Set: Allow the icing to set and harden on the cookies. This may take a few hours to overnight, depending on the thickness of the icing.

  8. Store: Store the decorated cookies in an airtight container to keep them fresh.

This rolled sugar cookie icing recipe is versatile and can be adapted to suit your preferences.You can adjust the consistency of the icing by adding more milk for a thinner glaze or more powdered sugar for a thicker, pipable icing. Experiment with different food coloring techniques, such as flooding or marbling, to create beautiful and artistic cookie decorations for any occasion.

Below you can find our editor's choice of the best rolled sugar cookie icing recipe on the market
  

Ideas for Decorating Cupcakes, Cookies & Cakes

Quarry Books

Based on 413 reviews Check latest price

Product features

Rick Reichart, cakelava, USA

There’s nothing like a dessert table, a Willy Wonka dream where everything is sweet, enticing, and edible. Even better? Seven dessert tables (some are pictured here), is what our family created when the whole town was invited to a scrumptious gala in celebration of our grandma’s ninetieth birthday. We were fortunate to grow up in a family of bakers, decorators, and overall party planners, where the preparation for the event was as much fun as the party itself. But we admit that there was some resistance from us, at first.

Liis Florides, www.tourtes.com, Cyprus

Remember grade-school bake sales? Our mother would send us to school with trays of colorful, beautifully decorated minicupcakes, which were always the first item to sell out. Once, we were foolish enough to say to Mom, “Cupcakes again? Why can’t we make Rice Krispies Treats like the other families?” But, our wise mother would smile and say, “You eat with your eyes!”

Jackie Rodriguez, www.lasdeliciasdevivir.com, Dominican Republic

Back then, despite our mom’s creativity, it seemed that overall there was much less experimentation in cake decorating. The big choice for a wedding cake was the color (or lack thereof) of the flowers. Now, in addition to more color and finish choices, items like edible markers and computer imaging have elevated this art form. The finished product can be anything from the most perfectly smooth fondant, to intricately modeled sugarplums.

Lindy Smith, www.lindyscakes.co.uk, UK

The following chapters present a visual feast for your inspiration: a range of confectionary treats that add magic to both special and everyday occasions. Your muse, for example, might be the seasons: the crystalline beauty of winter; the emerging flowers of spring; the sparkling celebrations of summer; or the changing displays of fall. Or, you may be attracted to the use of color, pattern, and composition. Think about how you can reinterpret a theme to create your own magic. And don’t be afraid to think outside the (cake) box! An elegant entertaining cake can be a wedding cake, as can a holiday cake, as can a … You get the idea.

Wilton Cookie Decorating Kit (12 Count)

Wilton

Product description

Celebrate spring with bright and cheerful cookies! The Wilton Deluxe Spring Cookie Decorating Kit includes everything you need to decorate 12 springtime cookies for your Easter celebration or just for a fun spring activity for the family. Complete cookie decorating kit includes 12 pre-baked cookies, sprinkles, icing, decorating bags and fondant. Pre-baked cookies include four flower shapes, four butterfly shapes and four Easter egg shapes. Sprinkles included feature one multi-color sugar and three decorating candies (confetti, mini pastels, flowers). Easter cookie kit makes it quick and easy to create custom cookies for your celebration or use the kit as a party activity or fun family activity.

  • Decorate 12 bright and cheerful cookies for your Easter or springtime celebration
  • Cookie kit makes a fun family or party activity, or a quick and easy way to create springtime custom cookies
  • Kit includes 12 pre-baked cookies, sprinkles, icing, decorating bags and fondant
  • Pre-baked cookies include flower, butterfly and Easter egg shapes
  • Sprinkles included feature one multi-color sugar and three decorating candies

Prepworks by Progressive 8-Piece Frosting Bulb Decorating Kit

Progressive International

Based on 1 reviews Check latest price

Product description

Progressive International is your source for the widest range of functional, inventive and fun kitchen tools and great ideas put into practice. Our gadgets, tools, food-prep items and household products make cooking and meal preparation more efficient and fun. At Progressive, passion and creativity unite to create the right balance of form and function for today's cooks. Our in-house designers spend hours in the kitchen coming up with ways to improve on a variety of traditional tasks and tools. Established in 1973, our commitment to quality and service allows us to offer a broad selection of quality kitchenware and other household products. Progressive holds product patents worldwide and has gained respect as a world class kitchenware innovator. Prepworks from Progressive International is a line of products created by people who understand having the correct kitchen tool can make your cooking experience more enjoyable. Prepworks-essential items for today's cook.

  • HAVE FUN DECORATING! Set of 2 frosting bulbs with 6 stainless steel piping tips; have fun decorating cookies, cakes and cupcakes
  • GREAT FOR ADDING ICING TO YOUR TREATS: High-Heat silicone bulbs are microwave safe up to 600 Degree F for heating toppings; fill the frosting bulbs with icing or warm ganache before piping
  • SIX DIFFERENT PIPING TIPS: Set of 6 piping tips include closed star, French tip, leaf, basket, small circles and large circles
  • 3/4 CUP CAPACITY: Frosting bulb can be used in the microwave; holds approximately 3/4 cup
  • DISHWASHER SAFE: Store tips inside the bulb when not in use; dishwasher safe

User questions & answers

Question: Are the bulbs hard to squeeze
Answer: No, they are a pliable silicone and are very easy to squeeze, in my judgment.
Question: Can you use other Tips? if so, what brand works well
Answer: I have tips from many different places, and they all fit. I have bought some at craft stores and wilton online. They all work, and hold a seal, although the ones it comes with do fit "perfectly".
Question: Are these hard to clean
Answer: These are particularly easy to clean (especially in comparison to traditional squeeze bottles).
Question: Can anyone compare these to the accordion style decorating bottle by OXO
Answer: This decorating bottle is 100% better to clean than any accordion style bottle.

Product features

Thoughtful Innovation for Every Cook

We create kitchen storage solutions and cooking tools to contribute to a healthier lifestyle while ensuring those solutions are budget friendly. Enjoy cooking from scratch with products that encourage using fresh ingredients, trying new recipes and entertaining friends and family.

Progressive International boasts over 40 years of thoughtfully innovating kitchen products essential to the everyday cook. What began as a small family of housewares products has grown into a collection of unique gadgets and tools dedicated to food preparation and storage.

As the kitchen is the heart of the home, our customers remain at the heart of what we do as an organization. At Progressive, our team is continually developing products intended to exceed the quality expectations of our customers.

Prep Solutions

Our Prep Solutions collection features innovative gadgets that will fit any lifestyle and budget at a great value.

SnapLock by Progressive

Our line of easy-to-open, leak-proof containers with unique hinged snap-off lids for all your family’s food storage needs.

Prepworks

Our Prepworks products are about convenience and control of everyday meal preparation for the busy home cook.

Wilton Fondant, 24 oz, Black

Wilton

Based on 2 reviews Check latest price

Product description

Decorate your cakes and other treats in bold color with our ready-to-use black fondant. You'll cover cakes smoothly and make accents in all kinds of different shapes including flowers, leaves, animals, ribbons, bows and more with this fondant icing You can even knead it with our other fondant colors to create custom shades or twist them together to get a marbleized look.

  • Prepackaged fondant icing is soft and easy to use
  • Color: Black
  • 24 oz. (680 g)
  • Certified Kosher
  • Made in a facility that also processes tree nuts, egg, milk and soy products

User questions & answers

Question: Does this turn your mouth black when you eat it
Answer: Crystal Light Fruit Punch Drink Mix (72 Pitcher Packets, 12 Packs of 6) This is enough to mix 36 gallons of fruit punch drink.
Question: After I cut this fondant into shapes how do you adhere them to a chocolate coated Oreo
Answer: Crystal Light Fruit Punch Drink Mix (72 Pitcher Packets, 12 Packs of 6) This is enough to mix 36 gallons of fruit punch drink.
Question: What size cake will this cover? I wanted to make a 2 tier cake (9 inch and 6 inch
Answer: yes - it's a good deal especially since my favorite flavor (raspberry) is no longer available in my grocery store
Question: how many time after open I have to finish it
Answer: Besides hydration, I don't think there are and real health benefits, but it is tasty ,thirst quenching and low in calories.

Product features

Pipe Dreams

A few disposable decorating bags filled with colored icing, couplers and piping tips are all it takes to make beautiful cupcakes. From a rosette to a flower in full bloom, you've got this with these buttercream tools.

Fondant Fun

Use fondant to add an extra dimension of design to cakes, cupcakes and cookies. Use your desired color of ready-to-use fondant, then cut or mold shapes using the fondant cut-out sets or impression mats and attach to your dessert. You can even take white fondant and mix it with other colors to create a marbleized effect that will add even more dimension to your designs.

Build Your Buttercream Skills

With Wilton tools and accessories, you can start sharpening your decorating skills. With decorating bags, piping tips and a practice board, you'll be able to perfect your techniques so that next time, you know whatever you decorate will turn out beautifully.

Wilton Black Cookie Icing

Wilton

Based on 979 reviews Check latest price

Product description

This quick-setting, microwavable icing is the perfect option for decorating sugar cookies or any other roll-out type of cookie. It's so easy to use, just heat and squeeze using the convenient cap and let your creativity run wild.

  • We make it easy
  • You make it
  • Amazing and delicious
  • Available from Wilton
  • Made in the United States

User questions & answers

Question: Are all these cookie icing colors Vegan
Answer: None of our products are certified Vegan, but we do use plant-based glycerin.
Question: Hello, will this icing become hard or remain wet after application? For example, for gingerbread cookies you need hard icing
Answer: Honestly, I was not impressed with this product. It was way too runny for the cookies and it ran off the cookies making a nasty mess; like I had overheated it in the microwave. It's too hard to use without heating it up. And then I barely heated it in the microwave and it was too runny. It also became watery. I ordered 8-10 bottles of assorted colors. Some of the colors did better, but overall I will never order them again. I work full time too and I was just trying to find a quicker way to make cookies without having to make all of my own Icing colors too for time's sake. In the end, it wasn't worth it though. If you order I hope you have better luck with it than I did. FYI; I've been decorating cakes and cookies for 35 years, so I'm not a novice to icing. This product is inferior in my professional opinion. If you can make your own; I would. I learned the hard way. Wish it was better news, but I would want the honest truth.

Product features

Pipe Dreams

A few disposable decorating bags filled with colored icing, couplers and piping tips are all it takes to make beautiful cupcakes. From a rosette to a flower in full bloom, you've got this with these buttercream tools.

Fondant Fun

Use fondant to add an extra dimension of design to cakes, cupcakes and cookies. Use your desired color of ready-to-use fondant, then cut or mold shapes using the fondant cut-out sets or impression mats and attach to your dessert. You can even take white fondant and mix it with other colors to create a marbleized effect that will add even more dimension to your designs.

Build Your Buttercream Skills

With Wilton tools and accessories, you can start sharpening your decorating skills. With decorating bags, piping tips and a practice board, you'll be able to perfect your techniques so that next time, you know whatever you decorate will turn out beautifully.

Wilton Cookie 9oz Icing, White

Based on 1 reviews Check latest price

Product description

Decorate professional-looking cookies with a smooth finish using quick setting, microwavable white cookie icing. It's easy to use: microwave bottle and then squeeze onto store-bought or homemade cookies. Add crisp white color to ghost, snowflake, skeleton and ball cookies. Covers about 1 dozen 3-inch cookies. Sets smooth in approximately 1 hour. Made in a facility that also processes eggs, soy and wheat products. Net weight 10 oz. (283 g).

  • Get a smooth finish on cookies using quick setting, microwavable white cookie icing
  • Easy to use: heat in microwave and then squeeze onto cookies
  • Covers about 1 dozen 3-inch cookies
  • Net weight 10 ounce. (283 gram)
  • Made in a facility that also processes eggs, soy and wheat products

User questions & answers

Question: can I put the icing in a pipe bag and use that insead
Answer: The fondant will just stick to coating. I have no problem getting it to adhere to other decorating materials. You simply drape it across or if you have cut out small items you can lightly apply pressure or run an paint brush dipped in water across the back surface.
Question: Could you use this for basic cupcake decorating
Answer: For rounds 4 in High/ 6 in,8 in,10 in,12in For sheets, 2in High 9 in x 13 in Thank you
Question: What is the purpose of microwaving it? Can I use it without microwaving ? And what difference will it make
Answer: After opening the package, for the first time. I only used half, in July and the other half in October. If some of it was a little hard, I put that part, in the microwave for 5 to 10 seconds. It became, soft long enough for me to cut some shapes. The shapes that I had made became hard as well.
Question: list of ingredients? does it contain corn syrup or other corn products
Answer: Crystal Light Fruit Punch Drink Mix (72 Pitcher Packets, 12 Packs of 6) This is enough to mix 36 gallons of fruit punch drink.

Product features

Cookie Baking and Decorating Essentials

From cheerful holiday cookies to warm, ooey-gooey chocolate chip cookies for the kids, Wilton has all of the baking essentials you’ll need for the job. Make a big batch of our roll-out dough, then use any of our cutters to cut out fun shapes. Use any of our fun and colorful icings to for easy decorating. Or, just sprinkle on some of our bright and colorful jimmies or nonpareils for a pop of fun. Whether you’re a beginner or a more expert baker, we have the tools you need for your everyday cookie creativity.

Flowers & Flyers Spring Garden Cookies

Use your favorite roll-out cookie dough to create these dreamy springtime treats. Cheerful garden shapes stand out on cookies decorated with royal icing. Make imprints with the Garden Fondant Cut-Outs Pattern Set and decorate in pastels you can easily make with our Color Right Performance Food Color System.

Classic Spritz Cookies

There’s nothing more classic than a spritz cookie for the holidays. These delicious little treats are easy to make using any one of our Wilton Cookie Presses. Interchangeable discs create all sorts of festive shapes including trees, snowflakes and more. Add a simple candy drizzle and some of our Wilton Jimmies and Sprinkles and you’ve got a fun to eat but easy to make treat to bring to your next cookie exchange.

Milk & Cookies Anyone?

Our Wilton Cookie Shot Glass Pan Set combines two iconic pairings for one delicious dessert. Use the pan and your favorite chocolate chip cookie dough to create the perfect party treat! Be sure to coat the inside of your cookie shot glasses with delicious melted Candy Melts candy to seal in drinks and liquid dessert fillings.

Wilton Pink Cookie Icing, 9-Ounce, Assorted

Based on 723 reviews Check latest price

Product description

Use this quick-setting, microwavable icing to cover your cookies with a smooth finish. Easy to use: Heat and squeeze onto cookies using the convenient control cap. Sets smooth in just 1 hour. One bottle covers about 12 (3 in.) cookies.

  • Quick-setting. Easy-to-use icing made specifically for cookies
  • Covers smooth. Use a spatula to ice cookies completely or create more intricate designs using bottle tip; sets smooth in 1 hour
  • 9 oz.
  • Covers approx. 12 cookies
  • Ready-to-use boxed

User questions & answers

Question: Will this show up good on chocolate frosting
Answer: No this product is not peanut free. Sorry about that. ShopBakersNook Staff.
Question: What Is The Shelf Life
Answer: It can be used to make decorations on pre-iced cakes, but would be too thin to be use as a icing coating (usless you want that like the thin icing used on angel food cakes). or to drizzle on cakes.
Question: Does this frosting harden up after awhile .....so that each cookie could be wrapped in plastic without the frosting smearing
Answer: We would not recommend that, as the instructions for use call for microwaving and kneading it to get the correct consistency. The packaging is made to achieve the right consistency, so we wouldn't be able to confirm results if you put it in a piping bag.
Question: El artículo dice que klego junto a otros pero no llego
Answer: Hello! You could use this on cupcakes if you'd like. Please note: Cookie Icing dries hard.
Question: Can this be used in candy molds
Answer: Microwaving the cookie icing emulsifies the ingredients so the icing gets to the correct consistency. Without microwaving the icing will be too runny.
Question: peanut free
Answer: Hi there, yes it does have corn syrup.
Question: Can this be used on cakes
Answer: It may temporarily stain your mouth or tongue, but the coloring is water-soluble and will fade pretty quickly.

Product features

Pipe Dreams

A few disposable decorating bags filled with colored icing, couplers and piping tips are all it takes to make beautiful cupcakes. From a rosette to a flower in full bloom, you've got this with these buttercream tools.

Fondant Fun

Use fondant to add an extra dimension of design to cakes, cupcakes and cookies. Use your desired color of ready-to-use fondant, then cut or mold shapes using the fondant cut-out sets or impression mats and attach to your dessert. You can even take white fondant and mix it with other colors to create a marbleized effect that will add even more dimension to your designs.

Build Your Buttercream Skills

With Wilton tools and accessories, you can start sharpening your decorating skills. With decorating bags, piping tips and a practice board, you'll be able to perfect your techniques so that next time, you know whatever you decorate will turn out beautifully.

Pipe Dreams

A few disposable decorating bags filled with colored icing, couplers and piping tips are all it takes to make beautiful cupcakes. From a rosette to a flower in full bloom, you've got this with these buttercream tools.

Fondant Fun

Use fondant to add an extra dimension of design to cakes, cupcakes and cookies. Use your desired color of ready-to-use fondant, then cut or mold shapes using the fondant cut-out sets or impression mats and attach to your dessert. You can even take white fondant and mix it with other colors to create a marbleized effect that will add even more dimension to your designs.

Build Your Buttercream Skills

With Wilton tools and accessories, you can start sharpening your decorating skills. With decorating bags, piping tips and a practice board, you'll be able to perfect your techniques so that next time, you know whatever you decorate will turn out beautifully.

Wilton Green Cookie Icing, 9 oz.

Wilton

Based on 1 reviews Check latest price

Product description

This quick-setting, microwavable cookie icing by Wilton is the perfect option for decorating sugar cookies or any other roll-out type of cookie. It's so easy to use, just heat, squeeze using the convenient cap and let your creativity run wild.

  • Easy-to-use icing made specifically for cookies
  • Use a spatula to ice cookies completely or create more intricate designs using bottle tip; sets smooth in 1 hour
  • Color: Green
  • Net Weight: 9 oz. (255 g)
  • Made in a facility that also processes egg, milk, soy and wheat products

User questions & answers

Question: Is there an expiration date for this product
Answer: I have them regularly in my shop. They do not have a date on them but I know they last about 6 mos.
Question: Does this icing dry and harder for stacking
Answer: Yes! You can stack or package cookies frosted with this icing. Just let it set up for around an hour!
Question: Why doesn't this product ship to California
Answer: Si llego !No recuerdo haber dicho lo contrario!
Question: Why is this color 10 dollars more than the same size bottles of all the other colors? Does this have something to do with baby yoda
Answer: I don't think it would solidify, unless you froze it?

Product features

Cookie Baking and Decorating Essentials

From cheerful holiday cookies to warm, ooey-gooey chocolate chip cookies for the kids, Wilton has all of the baking essentials you’ll need for the job. Make a big batch of our roll-out dough, then use any of our cutters to cut out fun shapes. Use any of our fun and colorful icings to for easy decorating. Or, just sprinkle on some of our bright and colorful jimmies or nonpareils for a pop of fun. Whether you’re a beginner or a more expert baker, we have the tools you need for your everyday cookie creativity.

Flowers & Flyers Spring Garden Cookies

Use your favorite roll-out cookie dough to create these dreamy springtime treats. Cheerful garden shapes stand out on cookies decorated with royal icing. Make imprints with the Garden Fondant Cut-Outs Pattern Set and decorate in pastels you can easily make with our Color Right Performance Food Color System.

Classic Spritz Cookies

There’s nothing more classic than a spritz cookie for the holidays. These delicious little treats are easy to make using any one of our Wilton Cookie Presses. Interchangeable discs create all sorts of festive shapes including trees, snowflakes and more. Add a simple candy drizzle and some of our Wilton Jimmies and Sprinkles and you’ve got a fun to eat but easy to make treat to bring to your next cookie exchange.

Milk & Cookies Anyone?

Our Wilton Cookie Shot Glass Pan Set combines two iconic pairings for one delicious dessert. Use the pan and your favorite chocolate chip cookie dough to create the perfect party treat! Be sure to coat the inside of your cookie shot glasses with delicious melted Candy Melts candy to seal in drinks and liquid dessert fillings.

Latest Reviews

View all