13 best key lime pies
Key lime pie is a popular dessert known for its refreshing and tangy flavor. It is often associated with Southern cuisine and is particularly famous in the Florida Keys, where key limes are grown. Here's what you need to know about key lime pies:
Ingredients: Key lime pie typically consists of a graham cracker crust, a creamy and tart filling made from key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and egg yolks. The pie is often topped with whipped cream or meringue.
Key Limes: Key limes are smaller and more tart than the regular Persian limes that you often find in grocery stores. The use of key limes is what gives the pie its distinctive flavor. However, due to the limited availability of key limes in some regions, many recipes use regular limes or bottled key lime juice as a substitute.
Crust: The crust is usually made by crushing graham crackers and mixing them with melted butter and sometimes a bit of sugar.This mixture is pressed into a pie dish and baked until it sets.
Filling: The filling is a simple mixture of key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and egg yolks. The acidity of the lime juice reacts with the condensed milk to thicken the filling without the need for baking.
Baking: Some key lime pie recipes call for baking the pie briefly to set the filling, while others are "no-bake" versions that rely solely on the acid from the lime juice to thicken the mixture.
Topping: Whipped cream or meringue is often used to top the pie. The choice between these two depends on personal preference. Meringue is made by whipping egg whites and sugar until stiff peaks form, and it's then browned in the oven for a lovely finish.
Chill Time: After preparation, the key lime pie is usually chilled in the refrigerator for a few hours to allow the flavors to meld and the filling to set.
Variations: While the classic key lime pie is the most well-known version, there are variations that incorporate ingredients like chocolate chips or swirls of chocolate fudge into the filling to add a different dimension of flavor.
Serving: Key lime pie is typically served cold, making it a delightful dessert for warm weather or after a hearty meal.
Regional Specialty: Key lime pie is considered a regional specialty of Florida and is often associated with Southern and Gulf Coast cuisine.
It's a beloved dessert that offers a delightful combination of sweet and tangy flavors, making it a favorite for many dessert lovers, especially those with a penchant for citrusy treats.
Below you can find our editor's choice of the best key lime pies on the market
M&M's Key Lime Pie White Chocolate Candies, 7.44 Oz (Pack of 2) "Limited Edition" Great for Easter Baskets and Egg Hunts, A Spring Time Treat
Generic
Product description
M&M'S White Chocolate Key Lime Pie Easter Candy is the perfect Spring treat. Tap into fresh Spring vibes with these white chocolate candies. M&M'S fans will love this new flavor just in time for Easter. Key Lime Pie flavored white chocolate centers surrounded by green and white candy shells will add fun to all your Easter celebrations. Add these white chocolate candies to Easter baked goods. Top cupcakes and birds nest cookies with these brightly colored white chocolate candies. They're the perfect Easter egg candy to hide in plastic eggs for Easter egg hunts. Fill Spring candy jars and dishes full of M&M'S White Chocolate Key Lime Pie candy. Add fun to your Spring decorating with M&M'S Easter candy. You won't want to leave out M&M'S White Chocolate Key Lime Pie candy in Easter baskets. There are endless ways to brighten up your Easter celebrations with M&M'S candy.
- M&M'S White Chocolate Key Lime Pie Easter Candy is the perfect Spring treat. Tap into fresh Spring vibes with these white chocolate candies.
- Key Lime Pie flavored white chocolate centers surrounded by green and white candy shells will add fun to all your Easter celebrations.
- Two Bags of 7.44oz, one bag just isn't enough
- They're the perfect Easter egg candy to hide in plastic eggs for Easter egg hunts. Fill Spring candy jars and dishes
- There are endless ways to brighten up your Easter celebrations with M&M'S candy
Bang Energy Drink, Key Lime, 0 Calories, Sugar Free with Super Creatine, 16 Fl Oz (Pack of 12)
BANG
Product description
Potent brain and body fuel make no mistake - BANG is not your stereotypical high sugar, life-sucking soda masquerading as an energy drink!
- Power Up with bang’s potent brain & body-rocking fuel: super CREATINE, caeine, nitro-jack & EAAs (essential amino acids).
- Life is an extreme Sport and bang is the extreme energy source to live life extreme!
- Includes 16oz cans
- 12 count
User questions & answers
| Question: | Does key lime have an aftertaste |
| Answer: | The only reason I drink Bang Energy drinks is because of this flavor alone. There is no unpleasant aftertaste whatsoever. I buy these all the time now from 711. The flavor in my opinion is a "Sweet Lime Cream Soda". |
| Question: | How much caffeine does this have |
| Answer: | 300 MG. Like 2 cups of coffee. Just drinking one now. |
Nellie & Joes: Key West Lime Juice, 16 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)
Nellie & Joe's
Product description
This famous juice is the original and has long been the favorite choice of America's bakers when preparing the very best Key Lime Pies.
- This famous juice is the original and has long been the favorite choice of America's bakers when preparing the very best Key Lime Pies.
User questions & answers
| Question: | Does it contain any sulfites, like sodium metabisulfite |
| Answer: | On the back of the bottle, the ingredients are listed as follows: Key West Lime Juice from concentrate, and less than 1/10 of 1% Sodium Benzoate as a preservative. |
| Question: | How long does it keep after you open the bottle and refrigerate please? it is difficult for me to use a whole bottle at once thanks |
| Answer: | I don’t know what the mfg would say but I have had an opened bottle for al least two weeks in my refrigerator. |
| Question: | Is this non gmo |
| Answer: | According to their webpage the answer is NON-GMO. Please visit the following link: https://keylimejuice.com/faq/#toggle-id-12 |
| Question: | what is the expiration date on this |
| Answer: | It is stamped on the side of the bottle. I can tell you it lasts quite a while. I nearly always use it all before expiration date. |
Whole Foods Market Key Lime Pie
Whole Foods Market
Product description
Bakery
- This item is typically available for pickup/delivery between 10am-6pm
- All artisanal breads, cakes, cookies and more from the Whole Foods Market Bakery department are baked with better ingredients, so you can feel good about what you’re buying (and eating). Here’s what you can count on with this selection:
- 100+ banned preservatives, flavors, colors, sweeteners and other ingredients commonly found in food
- No hydrogenated fats or high-fructose corn syrup
- No bleached or bromated flours allowed
Edward's, Single Serve Key Lime Pie, 6.5 oz (Frozen)
Schwan's
Product description
Key Lime Pie
- Made with real key west lime juice
- Treat your taste buds to the vacation they deserve
- Topped with whipped crème rosettes on a fresh-from-the-oven vanilla cookie crumb crust
M&Ms Limited Edition White Chocolate Key Lime Pie Candy - 7.44 oz Per Bag - Choose a 3, 4, or 6 Pack (4 Pack)
CC Goods
Product description
Easter is right around the corner, so that means it's time to stock up on Easter candy before its gone. You'll get 3, 4, or 6 bags (choose your size) of Key Lime Pie M&M's, each bag is 7.44 oz, making a grand total of 22.32 oz, 29.76 oz, or 44.64 oz. White chocolate goodness, with a hint of Key Lime for a spectacular taste.
- BULK M&M'S: You'll get 3, 4, or 6 bags (choose your size) of Key Lime Pie M&M's, each bag is 7.44 oz, making a grand total of 22.32 oz, 29.76 oz, or 44.64 oz.
- LIMITED EDITION M&M'S: These are limited edition M&M's, and won't be around forever, so stock up while you can.
- GREAT FOR CANDY BOWLS: Toss some of these bad boys into a bowl for a party, or just to have a reliable snack nearby at home.
- WHITE CHOCOLATE KEY LIME PIE: White chocolate goodness, with a hint of Key Lime for a spectacular taste.
- EASTER BASKETS: These are a great candy to put in Easter baskets, or you can put a few in an Easter egg for Easter egg hunts.
TORTUGA “Taste of Florida” Key Lime Rum Cake – 16oz The Perfect Premium Gourmet Gift
TORTUGA
- TORTUGA TASTE OF FLORIDA KEY LIME RUM CAKE: Whether you’re looking for personalized gourmet gifts for the rum cake lovers in your life or you’re just looking for delicious gourmet cake, this will sure be a hit!
- QUALITY: This is one of the best superior quality gourmet gift cakes on the market today and probably the last rum cake you will need to ever try! Just check our reviews.
- FINEST INGREDIENTS: We use only the finest high-quality ingredients, gourmet key limes, including our specially blended oak barrel aged 5 year old Tortuga gold rum that is applied by hand.
- ALWAYS FRESH: This key lime cake is baked fresh every day in the Cayman Islands, then its vacuum sealed to lock in the delicious freshness.
- PERFECT: The perfect gourmet gift for birthdays, father’s day, mother’s day, Christmas and any other holiday.
User questions & answers
| Question: | I just want to know the real size. In the title says "4 ounces" cake and the description says "16 ounces".? Conflicting advertising |
| Answer: | 16 |
Product features
TORTUGA Caribbean Coconut Rum Cake - The perfect premium gourmet gift for gift baskets, parties, holidays, and birthdays.
Freshly shredded coconut enhances the flavor of this TORTUGA Florida Coconut Rum Cake. Baked in the Caribbean with only the finest ingredients, each rum cake is hand glazed with special 5-year-old, oak barrel aged TORTUGA Gold Rum then vacuum sealed to lock in the delicious freshness.
The perfect gourmet gift for gift baskets, birthdays, father’s day, mother’s day, and makes an excellent Christmas gift stocking stuffer. Let your loved ones know you care with a gift from the islands!
Tortuga Rum Cakes
Iconic Caribbean treasure born from family tradition that has become the perfect gift to experience a taste of the islands.
The TORTUGA brand is well-known by the more than 20 million annual Caribbean tourists and cruise ship passengers. Tortuga Caribbean Rum Cakes are the #1 export of the Cayman Islands and named the 2012 "Best Cruise Souvenir" by Porthole Cruise Magazine for the eighth consecutive year.
Available in 4oz, 16oz, & 32oz
Our Flavors:
Dr Oetker Pie Filling Key Lime (Pack of 3)
Dr Oetker
Product description
Price is for one box of mix as shown. Best by Aug 24, 2018. Ships from Amazon. Check out ShopRunner on Amazon for other Dr. Oetker products including Lemon pie filling/mix.
- Meringue recipe included on box
User questions & answers
| Question: | Best by Aug 24,2018 ??????? Is this the true expiration date |
| Answer: | I suggest you write your question to the Mf. the address is on the box in New Jersey |
| Question: | Where are the cooking instructions? Other brands for sale list preparation details |
| Answer: | The instructions are on the box |
| Question: | is this gluten free |
| Answer: | This is an outstanding key lime pie but the box doesn't say gluten free. There's an email address on the box of www.oetker.us where you can ask that question on line or call 856-866-3566.... Good luck and it's worth pursuing. |
| Question: | What is the list of ingredients; have allergies |
| Answer: | It contains sugar,cornstarch,modified cornstarch, modified cornstarch,citric acid,salt, natural and artificial flavor, aceylated momoglycerdies yellow 5. It can be used as a pie filling or a pudding. |
J&M Foods Key Lime Cookies, 10 Ounce Tin
Product description
J and M Key Lime Cookies in a Gift Tin
- J and M
- Key Lime
User questions & answers
| Question: | Approximately how many cookies are in a package |
| Answer: | Ok |
| Question: | Confusing description...it is 10oz or 16oz? The image shows a 10oz box but the description says it's 1 lb. Their website doesn't show a 16oz box |
| Answer: | Says 10 oz. |
| Question: | Are these made in Florida |
| Answer: | The back of the tin states "J&M Foods, Little Rock, AR" and refers to the "taste of Florida". So I would say No but they are good and taste very close to the cookies we purchased when we visited FL. |
| Question: | How many cookies in a 10 oz tin |
| Answer: | I did not actually count them, but I would guesstimate between 12-18. They are about the size of a vanilla wafer but a little thicker. I hope this helps. |
Oui Layered Dessert Key Lime Pie 7oz
General Mills
Product description
Inspired by our traditional French recipe, Oui by Yoplait Key Lime Pie layered dessert combines 3 decadent layers of real fruit, our French style yogurt, and a golden crust to create a moment of pure enjoyment and goodness in every spoonful.
- Deliciously thick yogurt with a Subtly Sweet, fresh taste
- Oui by Yoplait is made with Simple Ingredients like whole milk and real fruit
- Cup set: Every pot of Oui yogurt is crafted to perfection and poured and set in its own glass pot for 8 hours
- Explore all of our new Oui Layered Desserts varieties, available in Cherry Cheesecake, Caramel Cheesecake, and Key Lime Pie
- Contains: 70 oz yogurt
Original Meringue Cookies (Key Lime) • 80 calories per serving, Gluten Free, Fat Free, Nut Free, Low Calorie Snack, Kosher, Parve • by Krunchy Melts
Jada Foods LLC
Product description
Meringue Cookies
- Gluten Free
- Fat Free
- Kosher Parve
- 80 calories per serving
User questions & answers
| Question: | Anyone have the nutritional information that shows grams of fat per serving |
| Answer: | Serving Size: 40 (22g) Serving per Container: About 5 Amount Per Serving Calories: 90 Calories from Fat: 0% |
| Question: | Can you buy with a EBT card |
| Answer: | No. |
| Question: | when will they be available |
| Answer: | YES |
| Question: | do they use real nongmo cane sugar, or gmo beets, or? no mention on package or website |
| Answer: | We use regular cane sugar. |
Twizzlers Filled Twists Key Lime Pie and Orange Cream Pop Bundle 2 Pack (11 ounce)
Twizzlers
- Twizzler bundle includes one 11 oz package of Key Lime Pie and one 11 oz package of Orange Cream Pop.
- Enjoy the tropical flavors of Florida with these Twizzler specialty flavors.
- Chewy dessert flavored candy twists.
- Perfect portable snack for car rides, vacation, and trips to the beach.
- Naturally and artificially flavored.
User questions & answers
| Question: | is it 2 pks ea, or |
| Answer: | 1+1=2 |
Uncle Butchs Key Lime Fudge one Half Pound
Uncle Butch
Product description
1/2 pound of Creamy Smooth Tart Key Lime Fudge ! We add no Preservatives
User questions & answers
| Question: | Gluten free |
| Answer: | The short answer is that fudge is “probably” gluten-free in most instances. The raw ingredients for fudge are typically sugar, butter, and milk (so those are gluten-free) but fudge can quickly become non gluten-free when it is flavored (chocolate, peanut butter, maple, etc.). It is impossible to cover all the different kinds of fudge out there, so you’ll need to read (or ask) about the ingredients. |
| Question: | would this make for a good birthday present |
| Answer: | Good morning, I do have people by fudge for birthday gifts. If the person receiving the gift loves Keylime I make it with real key lime juice not imitation flavoring. That would be in the eye of the beholder not trying to be funny, but it is a matter of taste again I do sell fudge for birthday gifts and it works out very well, thank you for asking and have a blessed day |
| Question: | Does this come in a gift box |
| Answer: | It is in a very nice white bakers box with a company logo with a Little Knife. Thank you |
| Question: | Any issues with shipping to South Florida; it’s very hot down here |
| Answer: | No I ship all over Florida just put it in the refrigerator for thirty minutes before opening! I’m in New Smyrna beach Florida |
Latest Reviews
View all
Usb Projector For Smartphone Pcs
- Updated: 21.01.2023
- Read reviews
Make Up For Ever Bag Evers
- Updated: 05.02.2023
- Read reviews
Epson 1080P Projectors
- Updated: 10.06.2023
- Read reviews
Warm Air Humidifier
- Updated: 12.06.2023
- Read reviews
Mr Coffee Ice Tea Makers
- Updated: 05.03.2023
- Read reviews